How New York Law Governs Security Deposit Refund Rules
PRIMARY SOURCE: N.Y. Gen. Oblig. Law § 7-108 // LAST VERIFIED: 2026-11-17
1. Statutory Overview and Deadline Mechanics
New York General Obligations Law Section 7-108, overhauled by the Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act of 2019, establishes strict statewide rules for non-rent-regulated residential security deposits. A landlord cannot collect a security deposit or advance payment exceeding one month of rent. After a tenant vacates the apartment, the landlord observes a 14-calendar-day Standard Statutory Window to deliver both an itemized written statement detailing the basis for any deposit retention and the remaining cash balance. Deductions cover unpaid rent, unpaid utility charges owed directly to the landlord under the lease, damage beyond ordinary wear and tear, and reasonable costs of moving or storing abandoned tenant belongings. If a landlord misses the 14-calendar-day deadline to deliver the itemized statement and remaining balance, Section 7-108(1-a)(e) states that the landlord forfeits any right to retain any portion of the deposit. Furthermore, under Section 7-108(1-a)(g), a court finding a willful violation may award actual damages alongside punitive damages reaching a Potential Statutory Maximum of twice the security deposit amount. Under General Obligations Law Section 7-103, landlords hold deposits in trust without commingling funds, and buildings with six or more units place deposits in interest-bearing New York bank accounts.
2. Statutory Exemptions, Carve-Outs, and Exceptions
Section 7-108(1-a) explicitly excludes dwelling units subject to rent stabilization or rent control, although Division of Housing and Community Renewal regulations separately cap rent-stabilized deposits at one month of rent and require prompt return at lease end. Bona fide seasonal use dwelling units rented for 120 days or fewer per year also qualify for narrow statutory exemptions when the lease records the tenant primary residence and county clerk registration data. Continuing care retirement communities, assisted living residences, and adult care facilities operating under Public Health Law or Social Services Law licenses follow distinct healthcare residency rules outside Section 7-108(1-a). Commercial leases also fall outside these residential consumer caps and 14-day forfeiture deadlines.
3. Independent Statutory Verification Checklist
Follow these jurisdiction-specific verification steps before relying on any deadline or penalty calculation:
- Confirm whether the apartment is market-rate or rent-stabilized by reviewing lease riders and requesting a rent history from New York Homes and Community Renewal.
- Review the pre-occupancy inspection agreement and any pre-move-out walk-through notice offered one to two weeks prior to surrender under Section 7-108(1-a)(d).
- Document the exact move-out and key-return date with time-stamped photographs, video walk-throughs, and written delivery confirmation of a forwarding address.
- Count 14 calendar days starting the day after vacating the unit to check postmark or electronic delivery dates on any itemized deduction statement.
- Inspect repair invoices and lease clauses to verify that claimed deductions exclude ordinary wear and tear such as faded paint or minor carpet wear.
4. New York Small Claims and Administrative Filing Procedure
New York splits small claims monetary limits across three geographic court tiers based on where the rental property sits or where the landlord resides or maintains an office. Inside the five boroughs, the New York City Civil Court Small Claims Part hears individual monetary claims up to $10,000. In Nassau County and Western Suffolk County District Courts, as well as City Courts outside New York City, the statutory small claims ceiling is $5,000. Across rural and suburban Town and Village Justice Courts statewide, the small claims monetary cap is $3,000. Claimants file a concise statement with the court clerk, pay a nominal filing fee of $15 to $20 depending on claim size, and have the clerk serve the defendant by certified and first-class mail. Hearings follow simplified evidentiary rules, and tenants may alternatively submit administrative mediation complaints to the New York State Office of the Attorney General.